Willpower doesn’t work, so go ahead and cheat

April 21, 2010 8:45 am
  • Pin It

Willpower doesn't work, so go ahead and cheat

Yesterday I wrote about  the importance of determining a few absolute rules with regards to eating.   Soon I’ll be writing more about my specific rules (it’s important to choose the right rules, of course), but for now I’m going to keep it somewhat conceptual.

Critical to the success of following any “absolute” rule is accepting that none of us is perfect. Completely depriving yourself of something you love doesn’t work in the long run. Sure, if you’re trying to drop a few pounds, you can make it work for awhile — but let’s think long term here.  Any changes you make to your life have to be sustainable, else what’s the point?

If you make a decision, say, to eliminate French Fries from your diet, but you truly love and crave pommes frites (and really, who doesn’t?), at some point you’ll have a breakdown and gorge on a whole bucket of them.  Willpower only goes so far.  Eventually those cravings will win out.

So here’s the magic bullet:  Have one “cheat meal” each week, in which you can eat anything you want.

Go ahead and eat those yummy fries without any guilt, and without triggering a downward spiral.  But you only get to cheat once a week.

Now, I’ll admit I’ve been a bit draconian in my posts so far:  Nutrition facts, rules, menu analysis, what-have-you.  But please don’t get me wrong:  I love food!  I love eating!  In fact, I think Eating Rules!   (See what I did there?)

I love most foods so much, in fact, that I wouldn’t dream of not eating them ever again.  I’m an artisanal foodie at heart.  Heck, I even make my own cheese, and my closest compatriots make their own pickles and brew their own beer!  Without the cheat meal, I’d be totally lost.

But here’s the real beauty of this concept:  I look forward to my cheat meal all week.  It’s an important part of my life, and informs how I approach food all week long.  It’s actually changed my relationship with food.

When I do get to have that special meal, I appreciate it that much more.  Those little potato morsels become a really wonderful treat that I savor and truly, deeply enjoy.  I don’t mindlessly scarf them down just because they’re in front of me.  In other words, I’m really making them count.

I’ve also found that I’m more inclined to stick with my healthful eating when I know that at the end of the week I can have a fantastic meal of Anything I Want as my reward.  It gives me something to look forward to (as if the weekend itself weren’t enough!).  It also makes eating at restaurants infinitely more manageable.

It doesn’t have to be on the weekend, of course.  Use a day that works for you… and it’s fine if it changes a bit each week.

One final thought:  The cheat meal isn’t carte blanche to gorge so much that you make yourself sick.  Yes, have those fries.  But don’t have three plates of ‘em!  A little common sense has to factor in here.  Keep it reasonable and keep it enjoyable.


“Cheat Meal” is actually somewhat of a misnomer… because if you’re supposed to do it, it’s not really cheating, is it?  Maybe it should be called a “Treat Meal”?  I’m open to suggestions here… any great ideas on renaming the Cheat Meal?  Post ideas in the comments, please!

French Fries” © 2006 umami, used under creative commons license.

“Cheat Meal” is actually somewhat of a misnomer… because if you’re supposed to do it, it’s not really cheating, is it?  Maybe it should be called a “Treat Meal”?  I’m open to suggestions here… any great ideas on renaming the Cheat Meal?  Post in the comments!
6 Comments on "Willpower doesn’t work, so go ahead and cheat"
  1. Comment left on:
    October 8, 2012 at 4:55 am
    Paula says:

    I’ve been doing this for months and it does help to have one day off. As a calorie counter, it really gives me such a break. I did fall into the trap of going too extreme (bingeing), but I’ve gotten over that since I’ve backed off a bit on the “never have this again” mentality.

  2. .
    January 1, 2013 at 1:57 pm

    [...] rules allow for 1 cheat meal per week. Right here is where I go ahead and admit that I started the new rules today and my cheat [...]

  3. Comment left on:
    March 13, 2013 at 12:12 am
    D.J. Perry says:

    You are right, “cheat meal” doesn’t quite fit if it’s part of the game. In the mind set of eating right being a fun, stress free game, how about calling it your “bonus meal”? You played by the rules all week and now you get the free bonus meal! I’m new to this, and I have to say I’m already pretty passionate about eating right. Thanks for all the helpful information! So far, so good : )

  4. Comment left on:
    March 23, 2013 at 8:11 pm
    Kimberly M. says:

    I think your “cheat meal” should be called the “Thank God” Meal.

  5. .
    April 1, 2013 at 12:04 am

    [...] the “Blasts” and smoothies — which all have quite a bit of added sugar. Unless it’s a cheat meal, it’s probably best to avoid all of those [...]

  6. .
    September 24, 2013 at 11:56 am

    […] AW: I’m friends with a lot of food bloggers, so I’ll get in trouble if I only call out a few of them! The best answer is to read the guest posts on my site throughout October — you’ll find a whole lot of wonderful bloggers contributing. As for when I just want to eat junk food? I’ll eat junk food! We can’t deprive ourselves completely, or we’ll never be able to stick with the plan. That’s why I’m such a big fan of the cheat meal! […]

Leave A Comment
Name (required)
Website Url (completely optional)
XHTML: feel free to use any of these tags.

Seeing unhealthful or otherwise icky ads? Please let me know.
© 2010-2014 Andrew Wilder / Eating Rules — All Rights Reserved.